Book Review: Come Rack, Come Rope

Come Rack, Come Rope is set in England during the reign of Queen Elizabeth, a time when practicing Catholicism could bring danger or even death. This historical fiction novel weaves real historical details into a gripping fictional story, following Catholic characters, mainly Robin and Marjorie, in how they respond to persecution and remain faithful to their beliefs.

The book contains rich elements of steadfastness in faith and the temptation to yield to the demands of the state. It explores the tension between religious and civic duties and the secret practice of the faith. The story also highlights hiding places for priests, navigating dangerous circumstances, and the varied responses of Catholics, with some engaging in conspiratorial resistance and others showing principled fidelity.

Robin’s character develops significantly throughout the story, beginning as a young man wrestling with difficult choices and growing into a figure of courage and fidelity. Marjorie is portrayed as a woman of deep faith whose devotion leads her to sacrifice much to support priests and Catholics in hiding. Much unfolds, including increasing persecutions through the rack and rope, yet the faithful continue to practice their faith in secret while ministering to families. The story builds to a powerful climax as we follow Robin, illustrating the workings of grace in his actions as he undergoes the trials before him.

This novel is very well written. It is long (nearly 400 pages) and takes time to develop, but it provides a vivid perspective on the choices faithful Catholics must make under persecution. Some remain steadfast, while others are tempted or turn under pressure. I particularly enjoyed this novel, though there are many characters and places, which can be confusing at times; keeping a list was helpful, especially since some are referred to by first name in some sections and by last name in others. I would recommend this book to anyone interested in Catholic literature, historical fiction, or gaining insight into the experience of religious persecution. It is a well-crafted work of historical fiction.